Thursday, June 7, 2012

中国裸官氾滥 高达2.7兆亿美元已转移出境

 
    (世界新闻网) 中国把配偶、子女和金钱送往国外的「裸官」氾滥,华府的监督机构「全球金融诚信」(Global Financial Integrity)报告说,从2000年到2009年,中国非法转移出境的金钱高达2兆7000亿美元,是墨西哥移转资金的五倍之多。这其中包括中国的贪腐官员、国营企业主管等,这些钱落脚地点的首选是美国,又以洛杉矶为最大站,已成为「贪官的天堂」。
   
       非法移出中国的钱主要被送往美国、欧洲、澳洲、加拿大、新加坡、马来西亚和泰国。报导引用加州胡桃市市议员林恩成(Joaquin Lim)的话说,美国的洛杉矶是中国这些「裸官」的天堂,他们把配偶子女秘密送到洛杉矶定居,自己继续在国内工作,继续把钱输送到洛杉矶。 (博讯 boxun.com)

   
     由于「裸官」和金钱移送海外猖獗,中共中央纪律检查委员会将执行一个防止官员迁往国外的「反出走」计画,将采行的措施包括没收官员的护照,和对官员在海外的家人登记,这些官员将无法获得高位。
   
      但在中国经常是上有政策,下有对策,中国官员和国营企业主管经常有公务和私人两本护照,即使公务护照被没收,仍有私人护照可遛出国。中共严格禁止官员和其家人拥有外国绿卡和护照,但官员常用假离婚的方式送配偶出国,在其贪腐案东窗事发后,再逃往配偶处。中国法律规定其公民每年移出海外的钱不得超过5000元,但人民经常利用澳门赌场洗钱,或设立进口公司,浮报发票的金额,因而可移出远超过所需要的金钱。
   
     洛杉矶时报6日引用中国官方数据报导,中国已大力取缔贪腐的官员和国营企业主管,「经济周刊」本周报导,检察官在过去12年起诉1万8478名试图携带不法取得的钱财逃往海外的官员和国营企业主管。周刊说,典型的的「裸官」是50多岁,接近退休年龄,并累积财富至少1300万美元。
   
      中国人民银行去年也意外公布一项机密研究,指出从1990年代中期至2008年,数以千计的政府官员和国营企业主管把8000亿人民币(按现在汇率相当1260亿美元)移到海外。
   
     中国反贪腐调查人员在调查成本超支和受贿事件累累的中国高铁计画时,发现铁道部首席工程师之一张曙光在洛杉矶县胡桃市拥有一栋五卧室五卫浴的地中海式房屋,那是他在九年前花84万元买的,而当时他的薪水是月薪365元。他的妻女都住在洛杉矶,调查人员怀疑他也有意离开中国,来美与妻女团聚。
   
     张曙光在2011年3月因「严重违反纪律」被开除,这项指控是贪腐的代名词。而在不久前,他的上司、铁道部长刘志军被免职。中国媒体上周报导,刘志军因「大量受贿」被开除党籍,但未提张曙光的下场。
   
      56岁的张曙光是一名「裸官」,这是指把配偶、子女和金钱移送海外,自己也准备开熘的官员。在中国发生一连串官员把公款浪费在情妇、豪宅、豪华车和赌博上的丑闻后,中国从2007年起严格监督官员,今年薄熙来案涉及他的妻子谷开来,把家族的钱用与英国商人海伍德在海外设立贸易公司的方式移出,使官员贪腐议题成为政府的首要议程。

中国网络实名制将从微博推广至博客和论坛


 
   
    来源;法广 中文网站 rfi.fr
     (博讯 boxun.com)

    作者 上海特约记者 曹国星
    6月7日,中国国务院国家互联网信息办公室、工业和信息化部在国新办网站上发布了关于《互联网信息服务管理办法(修订草案 征求意见稿)》,就微博实名制的扩大等规定,面向公众征求意见,征求意见将于2012年7月6日截止,新的条例将替代2000年旧的《互联网信息服务管理办法》。
   
    根据这项新的立法,中国的网络审查和言论监管将空前强化: 微博实名制将从5个试点城市扩展到全国范围,同时覆盖博客、论坛等;用户发布信息网站应当保留半年,并为公安机关、国家安全机关依法查询提供技术支持。
    本次新条款最值得注意的是,新条例的第十五条规定,提供“由互联网用户向公众发布信息”服务的互联网信息服务提供者,应当要求用户用真实身份信息注册。服务提供者“应当记录”其所接入的互联网信息服务提供者的真实身份信息、网站名称、互联网地址等信息。
   
    一般认为,该条例使用“由互联网用户向公众发布信息的服务”这一概念,通过这次立法,将实名制的适用范围从之前已经展开试点的微博客,拓展到了整个互动社交媒体,包括了现有的论坛、博客等。这就意味着对微博实名制问题,该“征求意见稿”将原本仅为北京市新闻办层级的地方规章的“微博实名制”的试点提升到了国务院条例级,将范围扩展到全国,而不止之前的5个城市试点。
   
    此前,微博的实名制推行并不顺利,而网络论坛、博客的实名制推广难度更大,但在以实名制掌握并震慑网络舆论的维稳思维下,实名制仍将稳步推进。
    该办法确认了中国网络管制的三个主要主体机构:国信办、工信部、公安部。国信办就是此前挂牌的国家互联网信息办公室,由国新办牵头成立,基本上是对国新办现有网络管制职权的确认。
   
    据条文规定,国新办负责互联网信息内容管理,协调关部门对互联网信息内容实施监督管理;工信部负责互联网行业管理,负责对互联网信息服务的市场准入、市场秩序、网络资源、网络信息安全等;公安部负责互联网安全监督,维护互联网公共秩序和公共安全,防范和惩治网络违法犯罪活动。
   
    该条例还专门规定,从事提供“由互联网用户向公众发布信息”的服务,及提供互联网信息搜索服务的许可条件、程序、期限及需要提供的材料等,由国新办规定,进一步加强了许可审批制度。同时,还强化服务提供者的安全管理责任,要求互联网信息内容主管部门、电信主管部门、公安机关和其他有关部门建立信息共享和信息通报制度。
   
    新的条例的十八条,规定了多达九款的各种禁止发布的网络信息,甚至包括“法律、行政法规禁止的其他内容的”这样的兜底条款,并规定,网络服务商有义务“立即停止发布、传输”,并保存有关记录,向互联网信息内容主管部门、公安机关报告。
   
    征求意见稿还明确规定,“互联网信息服务提供者应当记录所发布的信息和服务对象所发布的信息,并保存6个月”;“互联网信息服务提供者、互联网接入服务提供者应当记录日志信息,保存12个月,并为公安机关、国家安全机关依法查询提供技术支持”。

Sunday, June 3, 2012

350人被卷入安全部成为美国间谍案 胡锦涛下令彻查

 
    
     (法广) 中国安全部官员涉嫌为美国搜集情报案继续发酵。周五出版的『纽约时报』称,中国在年初逮捕了一名安全部官员,原来这是一位披着中国安全官员外衣的美国间谍。该报指此案和薄熙来事件后续发展有关。无论如何,此案为秋后召开的中共十八大平添了神秘离奇的气氛。不过,美国与中国政府均对此保持缄默。
   
       『纽约时报』引述知情人士说,被拘捕的是中国安全部工作人员。香港杂志『新维』则披露,被捕的是安全部副部长助理,而且披露共有350人卷入了这起间谍案。
   
      据『纽约时报』披露,安全部副部长助理涉案本身令人不可思议,因为处在这一位置上经手中国最敏感的情报。据指出副部长助理可能在美国读书时被中央情报局招募为特工。该刊还透露,事情爆发后,在中共高层引起震惊,胡锦涛大怒,下令彻查。
    
    『纽约时报』报道说,此案爆发在中美关系微妙时期。2月份,中国“超级警官”王立军进入重庆美国领事馆,据指向美方披露了揭露薄熙来以及薄熙来妻子谷开来涉嫌犯罪的关键情报。
   
       『纽约时报』引述匿名的美国官员的说法指此案和薄熙来事件后续发展有关, 这位美国官员说,前中共重庆市委书记薄熙来出事后,北京当局在相同时间逮捕一名中国国家安全官员进行调查,全案由高阶领导授权,调查已由薄熙来扩大到国家安全部。有分析称这次国安间谍案可能使主管安全工作的政治局常委周永康受到巨大压力。
   
       正在奥斯陆访问的美国国务卿希拉里不愿就此发表评论。不过,一位匿名的美国国务院高官披露:这位间谍被捕的阶段与中共调查薄熙来案为同一时期。
   
     据指这名副部长助理被美国中央情报局策反后,向美国提供了政治、经济和战略情报,不过目前还不清楚这位部长助理提供的情报属于什么级别。
   
秘书当间谍的国安副部长不是邱进 是陆忠伟

    
    (明镜网) 西方媒体爆出中国逮捕了涉嫌当美国间谍的某国安部副部长的秘书后,人们纷纷猜测这位国安部副部长是谁?不少媒体推测是第一副部长邱进。但北京知情人士向明镜新闻网透露,这位国安部副部长,其实是陆忠伟。
       《纽约时报》等西方媒体纷纷报导,中国在年初逮捕了一名国安部官员,中了美国中央情报局的「美人计」被招募为间谍,并披露此人担任国安部某副部长的秘书。随后传闻这位副部长是邱进,顿时使此事平添诡异离奇的气氛,因为邱进不仅是共青团派重要成员,在胡锦涛、李源潮都在团中央任职时,他是团中央学校部的副处长,全国学联副秘书长,当时他的顶头上司正是即将接掌国务院的李克强;而且正是邱进被派专程从北京前往成都,将滞留在美国驻成都总领事馆的王立军带回首都。他的秘书被爆出充当美国CIA间谍,就使薄熙来、王立军案增加了新的想象空间。
   
       但知情人士告诉明镜新闻网,说是邱进的秘书当间谍,实在是张冠李戴了。秘书涉嫌间谍的其实是2011年被任命为国安部副部长的陆忠伟。
    
350人被卷入安全部成为美国间谍案 胡锦涛下令彻查

   
      陆忠伟简历如下:
   
      陆忠伟,1953年10月生,上海人。中共党员。研究员,博士生导师,享受国务院特殊津贴专家。
   
     他在北大荒8510农场工作4年,1977年毕业于黑龙江大学外语系日语专业,在中国现代国际关系研究所从事日本经济研究工作。1985年任中国现代国际关系研究所东亚研究室副主任(1986年-1987年任日本亚洲经济研究所客座研究员)。1992年任中国现代国际关系研究所东亚研究室主任、研究员。1993年5月任中国现代国际关系研究所副所长。1999年9月任中国现代国际关系研究所所长、中国现代国际关系研究院院长,中日21世纪委员会委员、秘书长,中国国际关系研究会副会长,中国军控学会副会长。2011年任国家安全部副部长。

Tiananmen Memorials Prompt Clampdown

2012-06-01
Chinese state security police take away an organizer of a Tiananmen public memorial event.
Wikipedia
Tiananmen Mothers founding member Ding Zilin in an undated photo.
The organizer of a public memorial event marking the 23rd anniversary of the bloody Tiananmen Square crackdown has been taken away by state security police, amid calls for a change in government attitude towards dissent ahead of a key leadership transition in the ruling Chinese Communist Party.

"They didn't detain my father during the day, but they came in the evening and took him away," said Mei Zuheng, son of Mei Chongbiao, who organized a commemorative event in the People's Square in the southwestern city of Guiyang earlier this week.

"Now my mother can't get in touch with my father ... Please can you help us to publicize my father's case on the Internet, so that at the very least they won't be able to do anything too bad to him," he said.

Fellow Guiyang-based activist Liao Shuangyuan said the apparent "loosening" of restrictions on public memorials for those who died in the 1989 crackdown has been an illusion.

"They were only loosening the reins so as to get a tighter grip on them," Liao said. "I heard that there were dozens of plainclothes police there at the time but that they didn't detain anyone."

"Now quite a few people have been detained, so maybe the powers that be gave the order to detain people."

The number of people killed when People's Liberation Army (PLA) tanks and troops entered Beijing on the night of June 3-4, 1989 remains a mystery.

Official toll

Beijing authorities once put the death toll at "nearly 300,"  but the central government, which labelled the six weeks of pro-democracy protests a “counterrevolutionary uprising,” has not issued an official toll or name list.

The crackdown, which officials styled in a news conference at the time as a necessary way to suppress a counterrevolutionary rebellion, sparked a wave of international condemnation, and for several years China was treated as a near-pariah, as Western governments offered asylum to student leaders fleeing into exile.

The Chinese Red Cross initially reported 2,600 deaths but quickly retracted its statement, while the Tiananmen Mothers, which represents all victims of the crackdown who died or were maimed, says it has confirmed 186 deaths, although not all at the hands of the army.

The group, which has repeatedly called for a dialogue with Chinese officials on a reappraisal of the crackdown, and for victims' families to be allowed to pursue legal claims against the government, issued a statement on Thursday, saying the administration of president Hu Jintao and premier Wen Jiabao had failed to deliver on promises of political reform.

"We think that there have been no new politics under Hu Jintao's administration, and that his political ideology has become more and more rigid," said Tiananmen Mothers founder Ding Zilin, whose 17-year-old son died in the bloodshed.

"They are cracking down tighter and tighter in the name of maintaining stability, and this has led to an intensification of social conflict, a widening gap between rich and poor," Ding said. "We are very upset by this."

The statement called on the government to overturn injustices left over from the June 4 crackdown and to make systemic changes to ensure that such a mass movement wouldn't happen again.

"As long as this group exists, we will continue to fight for the truth, for compensation, and for those responsible to be brought to justice," it said.

Black clothes

Meanwhile, the overseas-based rights website Jasmine Revolution, called on ordinary Chinese to wear black clothes and sunglasses between the early hours of June 4 and the following day, when most of the deaths are believed to have occurred.

Retired Nanjing University professor Sun Wenguang said he was optimistic that the government was in fact considering a reappraisal of the Tiananmen Square protests and the killings that followed.

"Older and middle-aged people all know that this was the oppression of a student movement," Sun said. "It totally destroyed China's reform process, and people have been wanting a reappraisal for a long time now."

"Now, it seems, there are people pushing for this behind the scenes in central government, so everyone is even more hopeful now," he said.

Meanwhile, a book of interviews with disgraced former Beijing mayor Chen Xitong went on sale in Hong Kong on Friday, in which he fights back against his popular image as a supporter of military intervention.

Chen, now on medical parole for cancer treatment, said in an interview with researcher Yao Jianfu that the Tiananmen crackdown should never have happened and that he hoped the government would formally re-evaluate the event.

"Chen said it was a tragedy that could have been avoided and that he hoped in his heart that the incident could have been resolved peacefully but in the end it wasn't," Yao told the Associated Press.

"I asked him how he felt as mayor at that time to see so many innocent civilians killed, and he said he felt very sorry," Yao said.

Yao said that Chen maintains that he dealt mostly with logistics, and that power over the capital's police and other security forces as well as the judiciary lay with Beijing's then-Communist Party boss Li Ximing.

Li, who died in 2008, and Chen were both credited with advocating the assault on the night of June 3-4, 1989 in the Tiananmen Papers, a compilation of purported internal documents on the crackdown published overseas in 2001.

Reported by Qiao Long and Xin Yu for RFA's Mandarin service. Translated and written in English by Luisetta Mudie.

Shandong Enforcer Loses Job

2012-06-01
The removal of a powerful Chinese provincial official is linked to the treatment of blind activist Chen Guangcheng.
AFP
Plainclothes security on April 28, 2012 monitor the entrance to Dongshigu Village in Shandong Province from where Chen Guangcheng escaped house arrest.
Authorities in the eastern Chinese province of Shandong have announced the removal from office of the province's most powerful law enforcement official, Bai Jimin, in a move which analysts said could be linked to local officials' treatment of blind Chinese dissident Chen Guangcheng.

"The Shandong provincial Party plenum chose a new provincial [ruling Chinese Communist] Party committee on May 28," the official China Economic News service reported this week.

"From now on, Liu Wei will no longer hold the post of deputy provincial Party secretary, while former standing committee members Wang Renyuan, Yan Rongzhu and Bai Jimin will no longer hold the posts of standing committee members."

Li Xiangyang, a rights lawyer from the same village as Chen, said that Bai, formerly provincial head of the powerful Party politics and law committee, would have had direct responsibility for the jailing and subsequent house arrest, as well as beatings meted out to Chen and his family over a seven-year period.

"The politics and law committee is in charge of law enforcement and the maintenance of stability," Li said. "The measures against Chen Guangcheng were a form of stability maintenance."

"Chen Guangcheng's case definitely wasn't being handled by the politics and law committee secretary in Linyi city, but was a case that was managed directly by the politics and law committee at national level," he added.

"This means that the Shandong provincial-level politics and law committee would have had to be involved as well."

But he said Bai's transfer didn't mean that Chen's request that his persecutors be investigated and punished was being met.

"Their acceptance of Chen Guangcheng's demands for a full investigation into those who persecuted him was a lie," Li said. "The Communist Party has always used lies and violence to carry out its business."

"If they were to investigate those who persecuted Chen Guangcheng, then wouldn't they just be investigating themselves?"

Chen, who is now living with his family in New York following a daring escape from 19 months of house arrest at his home village of Dongshigu, near Linyi city, has repeatedly called on Beijing to bring to justice those who held him in illegal detention and beat him and his wife, Yuan Weijing.

Lower status

Bai, 58, has now been reassigned to the lower status post of chairman of the provincial People's Congress.

Shandong-based retired university professor Sun Wenguang said the apparent demotion of Bai showed a clear link to Chen's ordeal.

"The Chen Guangcheng case was a huge one for Shandong, and he is sure to have been consulted when they were in the middle of [prosecuting and detaining him]," Sun said.

"Another reason ... is that all the politics and law committees have overstepped their legal remit recently, and they have carried out a lot of illegal actions."

Sun said the Party leadership would likely seek to bring the politics and law committees to heel ahead of the forthcoming 18th Party Congress and a leadership transition and amid a political crisis sparked by the ouster of former Chongqing Party chief Bo Xilai.

Chen's daring escape from his tightly guarded home in Shandong's Dongshigu village and flight to the U.S. Embassy in Beijing, where he sought refuge for nearly a week, came just ahead of annual strategic dialogues between U.S. and Chinese officials, prompting a diplomatic crisis and frantic behind-the-scenes negotiations.

Reported by Wen Jian for RFA's Mandarin service. Translated and written in English by Luisetta Mudie.

Google Launches Anti-Censorship Tool

2012-06-01
The retooled search site informs Chinese users when keywords will yield blocked results.
RFA
A screenshot of Google's Hong Kong-based search website displaying a notification about a sensitive search term.
Google has launched a new feature for its Chinese language site which informs mainland users when they enter search keywords that are likely to be blocked by censors and recommends using alternative terms, following a government crackdown on information about a major political scandal.

The move was announced Thursday on a blog post by senior Google vice president Alan Eustace as a site improvement, but did not address Beijing’s use of censorship to police the Internet in China.

Google left China in 2010 after a showdown with the government over Internet controls and currently redirects Chinese language users from the mainland to a search site run from its Hong Kong-based servers.

But Eustace said that mainland users accessing the Hong Kong site were experiencing connection breaks when they searched for certain terms.

“Over the past couple years, we’ve had a lot of feedback that Google Search from mainland China can be inconsistent and unreliable,” Eustace wrote in the blog entry.

“It depends on the search query and browser, but users are regularly getting error messages like ‘This webpage is not available’ or ‘The connection was reset.’ And when that happens, people typically cannot use Google again for a minute or more.”

Google said the problem also extends to users accessing the site via web browsers on their mobile phones, including devices operating on the company’s Android operating system.

He said that Google had examined its own systems and found no problems, but “noticed that these interruptions are closely correlated with searches for a particular subset of queries.”

“So starting today we’ll notify users in mainland China when they enter a keyword that may cause connection issues. By prompting people to revise their queries, we hope to reduce these disruptions and improve our user experience from mainland China,” Eustace wrote.

Users who wish to continue with their original search keywords may do so.

‘Sensitive’ terms

Eustace said the company had reviewed the 350,000 most popular search queries in China in an effort to find "disruptive queries."

Google listed the Chinese character “jiang,” which means river, as an example of a term that would likely lead to a broken connection, but neglected to mention that it is also the surname of former president Jiang Zemin, which could be the reason for blocked results.

A notification that pops up when entering such a character during a search query recommends that the user removes the offending term.

But the character “jiang” and others like it are used in many different words, including the names of places and businesses, and users who remove the term from their search will be unable to access related sites.

For users who do not want to remove the offending search term, Google suggested a workaround in which one can search using the “pinyin,” or Romanized version, of a Chinese word. It said writing in pinyin would not cause a user’s connection to break and would produce normal search results.

Web controls

Chinese web administrators do not publish a list of banned keywords, and such searches generally lead to generic error messages. Authorities are likely to be unhappy about Google pointing out the sensitive terms.

And while Google shut down the majority of its mainland operations in 2010, it does maintain a network of advertising sales offices in China, which could be targeted if Beijing decides to punish the company.

In the first quarter of 2012, Google held just over 16 percent of the search market in China—second behind domestic brand Baidu Inc. with a more than 78 percent share.

The company is pushing its Android mobile phone operating system to Chinese manufacturers and purchased a wireless device maker last month in a deal that Beijing approved on condition that the platform remains available to Chinese companies and others at no cost for five years.

China has the world’s largest population of Internet users at 513 million as of last December, but often blocks content it deems politically sensitive.

The most recent example of an Internet crackdown follows significant online traffic related to a political crisis sparked by the ouster of former Chongqing Party chief Bo Xilai.

The secrecy surrounding Bo's scandal has set China's Internet alight with political rumors, which the authorities have moved swiftly to quell through controls on the country's wildly popular Twitter-like services, known as "weibo."

Bo’s name is currently a blocked term, as are Chongqing and even the Yangtze River.

Reported by Joshua Lipes.

举家移民准备后路 裸官现象已造成党内危机

 
     核心提示:中国的官员们正在寻找抽身而退的策略,将家人和财产向国外转移。
   
     原文:Hedging their bets 来源:《经济学人》 (博讯 boxun.com)

    发表:2012年5月26日
   
      本文由"译者"志愿者翻译并校对
   
       "裸官"这个词,是安徽省的一名官员和博客作者周蓬安于2008年提出来的,它用来形容那些其家庭成员携财产移居海外的官员。这样一旦东窗事发,比如接受反腐调查等, 那些独自留在国内的官员(是为"裸")就能逃出中共的控制。周鹏安说,"裸官"现象造成了党内的信任危机,因为官员常用爱国主义和清正廉洁来教育下属,却把自己的家人送往国外。
   
      不过,你并不一定身涉腐败才能"裸",将家人送往国外仅是一种"有备无患"的状态罢了。这昭示着(他们)对中国未来稳定并没有太多的信心。许多富商也正筹划着抽身之道。最常见的合法途径之一包括美国、加拿大以及香港的投资移民项目——通常需要高至100万美元的投资数额。中国人对这些移民项目趋之若鹜——去年,美国移民项目中四分之三的申请者是中国人。
   
     财力较少一些的富人则从其他国家——南太平洋、非洲或者拉美等——以更能接受的价格(仅2万美元)获得护照。北京大学廉政建设研究中心主任李成言表示,那些尚未与中国签订引渡条约的国家倍受贪官们的欢迎。一位前云南省省长落马后,被发现拥有五国护照。"这样他们出逃时就不必再等待签证了。"李成言说。
   
       "裸官"们通常会先把子女送往海外求学。或许最着名的例子就是不久前刚被清除出党的重庆市委书记薄熙来了。薄的儿子薄瓜瓜,目前正于哈佛攻读硕士研究生学位,他先后毕业于英国的哈罗公学和牛津大学。据《纽约时报》报道,薄的妻子谷开来——目前因涉嫌谋杀在重庆的英国商人而被拘留,她也曾在海外居住过,他们整个家族的财产超过一亿美元。
   
     中国政府对"裸官"现象睁一只眼闭一只眼,罕有作为。他们仅仅在去年才开始监查官员家庭及其财产的下落,且仅是要求官员们填一份表格。2011年,央行在其网站上发布了援引自中国社科院的一份评估报告,称1995-2008年间共有一万八千名官员外逃,席卷走了总共8000亿元财产(按最新汇率折合美元1300亿)。央行随即声称数据并不准确,并从他们网站上抹去了这篇文章(尽管无法从读过该文的人们记忆里抹去)。首席检察长曹建明声称,2011年外国政府协助追捕了1631名中国涉嫌"职务犯罪"的外逃人员(包括政府官员和国企员工),并追回了78亿赃款。
   
     一些高层官员已经在推动改革。1月份,位于华南的广东省宣称,家属移居海外的官员将不能担任高级职位。不过这仅仅是例外罢了。有能力将家人移居海外的官员通常最有权势,对中国的问题也认识最深。北京大学的李主任表示,"他们比任何人都清楚,中国模式是不可持续的,而这对每个人来说都是危机。"